Definition
Homeopathy, or homeopathic medicine, is a holistic
system of treatment that originated in the late eighteenth
century. The name homeopathy is derived from two
Greek words that mean “like disease.” The system is
based on the idea that substances that produce symptoms
of sickness in healthy people will have a curative effect
when given in very dilute quantities to sick people who
exhibit those same symptoms. Homeopathic remedies
are believed to stimulate the body’s own healing processes.
Homeopaths use the term “allopathy,” or “different disease,”
to describe the use of drugs used in conventional
medicine to oppose or counteract the symptom being
treated.
Origins
Homeopathy was founded by the German physician
Samuel Hahnemann (1755-1843), who was much disturbed
by the medical system of his time, believing that
its cures were crude and some of its strong drugs and
treatments did more harm than good to patients. Hahnemann
performed experiments on himself using Peruvian
bark, which contains quinine, a malaria remedy. He
concluded that in a healthy person, quinine creates the
same symptoms as malaria, including fevers and chills,
which is the reason why it is effective as a remedy. He
then began to analyze the remedies available in nature by
what he called provings. Provings of homeopathic remedies
are still compiled by dosing healthy adults with various
substances and documenting the results, in terms of
the dose needed to produce the symptoms and the length
of the dose’s effectiveness. The provings are collected in
large homeopathic references called materia medica or
materials of medicine.
Hahnemann formulated these principles of homeopathy:
• Law of Similars (like cures like)
• Law of the Infinitesimal Dose (The more diluted a remedy
is, the more potent it is.)
• Illness is specific to the individual.
Hahnemann’s Law of Similars was based on thinking
that dated back to Hippocrates in the fourth century
B.C. It is the same thinking that provided the basis for the
vaccines discovered by Edward Jenner and Louis Pasteur.
These vaccines provoke a reaction in the individual
that protects against the actual disease. Allergy treatments
work the same way. By exposing a person to
minute quantities of the allergen, the person’s tolerance
levels are elevated.
The Law of the Infinitesimal Dose has always
caused controversy among those outside the field of
homeopathy. Hahnemann contended that as he diluted
his remedies with water and alcohol and succussed, or
shook, them, the remedies actually worked more effectively.
In fact, diluted homeopathic remedies may have
no chemical trace of the original substance. Practitioners
believe that the electromagnetic energy of the original
substance is retained in the dilution, but the toxic side effects
of the remedy are not. It is this electrochemical
“message” that stimulates the body to heal itself.
Homeopathic practitioners believe that illness is
specific to an individual. In other words, two people with
severe headaches may not receive the same remedies.
The practitioner will ask the patient questions about
lifestyle, dietary habits, and personality traits, as well as
specific questions about the nature of the headache and
when it occurs. This information gathering is called profiling
or case-taking.
In the early 1900s, homeopathy was popular in
America, with over 15 percent of all doctors being
homeopaths. There were 22 major homeopathic medical
schools, including Boston University and the University
of Michigan. However, with the formation of the American
Medical Association, which restricted and closed
down alternative practices, homeopathy declined for half
a century. When the 1960s revived back-to-nature trends
and distrust of artificial drugs and treatments, homeopathy
began to grow again dramatically through the next
decades. In 1993, The New England Journal of Medicine
reported that 2.5 million Americans used homeopathic
remedies and 800,000 patients visited homeopaths in
1990, and homeopathy has continued to grow. Homeopathy
is much more popular in Europe than in the United
States. French pharmacies are required to make homeopathic
remedies available along with conventional medications.
Homeopathic hospitals and clinics are part of
the national health system in Britain. Homeopathy is
also practiced in India and Israel, among other countries.
Benefits
Homeopathic physicians seek to cure their patients
on the physical, mental and emotional levels, and each
treatment is tailored to a patient’s individual needs.
Homeopathy is generally a safe treatment, as it uses
medicines in extremely diluted quantities, and there are
usually minimal side effects. Its nontoxicity makes some
consider it a good choice for the treatment of children.
Another benefit of homeopathy is the cost of treatments;
homeopathic remedies are inexpensive, often a fraction
of the cost of conventional drugs.
Homeopathic treatment has been shown to be effective
in treating many conditions. Colds and flu may be effectively
treated with aconite and bryonia. Influenza sufferers
in a double-blind study found that they were twice
as likely to recover in 48 hours when they took homeopathic
remedies. Studies have been published in British
medical journals confirming the efficacy of homeopathic
treatment for rheumatoid arthritis. Homeopathic remedies
are considered effective in treating infections, circulatory
problems, respiratory problems, heart disease, depression
and nervous disorders, migraine headaches, allergies,
arthritis, and diabetes. Homeopathy is a treatment
to explore for acute and chronic illnesses, particularly if
these are found in the early stages and where there is not
severe damage. Homeopathy can be used to assist the
healing process after surgery or chemotherapy.
Description
A visit to a homeopath is usually a different experience
from a visit to a regular physician. Surveys have
shown that homeopathic doctors spend much more time
during initial consultations than conventional doctors
spend. This is because a homeopath does a thorough
case-taking to get a complete picture of a person’s general
health and lifestyle, as well as particular symptoms, on
the physical, mental and emotional levels. Some symptoms
can be so subtle that the patient is not always completely
aware of them, and the doctor must spend time
getting to know the patient.
The initial visit often includes a long questionnaire
about a patient’s medical and family history, and then a
long interview with the doctor, who prompts the patient
with many questions. Sometimes a homeopathic doctor
will use lab tests to establish a patient’s general level of
health. The initial interview usually lasts between one
and two hours.
The purpose of homeopathy is the restoration of the
body to homeostasis, or healthy balance, which is its natural
state. The symptoms of a disease are regarded as the
body’s own defensive attempts to correct its imbalance,
rather than as enemies to be defeated. Because a homeopath
regards symptoms as positive evidence of the
body’s inner intelligence, he or she will prescribe a remedy
designed to stimulate this internal curative process,
rather than suppress the symptoms.
In homeopathy, the curative process extends beyond
the relief of immediate symptoms of illness. Healing may
come in many stages, as the practitioner treats layers of
symptoms that are remnants of traumas or chronic disease
in the patient’s past. The stages are related to Hering’s
Laws of Cure, named for Constantine Hering, the father of
homeopathy in America. Hering believed that healing
starts from the deepest parts of the body to the extremities,
and from the upper parts of the body to the lower parts.
Hering’s Laws also state that homeopaths should treat disease
symptoms in reverse chronological order, from the
most recent to the oldest, restoring health in stages. Sometimes,
the patient may feel worse before feeling better.
This temporary worsening is called a healing crisis.
When prescribing a remedy, homeopaths will match
a patient’s symptoms with the proper remedy in a repertory
or materia medica that has been compiled throughout
the history of homeopathy. Classical homeopaths
prescribe only one remedy at a time. However, it is becoming
more common, especially in Europe, to use combination
formulas of several remedies for the treatment
of some combinations of symptoms.
The cost of homeopathic care can vary. The cost of
visits will be comparable to conventional medicine, with
initial visits ranging from $50 to $300. Non-M.D. homeopaths
can charge from $50 to $250. Follow-up visits are
less, at about $35 to $100. Homeopathic medicine is significantly
cheaper than pharmaceuticals, and most remedies
cost between $2 and $10. Some doctors provide
remedies without charge. Homeopaths rarely use lab
tests, which reduces the cost of treatment further. In general,
homeopathy is much more economical than conventional
medicine. In 1991, the French government did a
study on the cost of homeopathic medicine, and found
that it costs half as much to treat patients, considering all
treatment costs involved.
When homeopaths are licensed professionals, most
insurance companies will pay for their fees. Consumers
should consult their insurance policies to determine individual
regulations. Insurance usually will not cover homeopathic
medicine, because it is sold over the counter.
Precautions
Although homeopathic remedies sometimes use substances
that are toxic, they are diluted and prescribed in
non toxic doses. Remedies should be prescribed by a
homeopathic practitioner. Those preparing to take homeopathic
remedies should also avoid taking antidotes, which
are substances that homeopathic doctors believe cancel
the effects of their remedies. These substances include alcohol,
coffee, prescription drugs, peppermint (in toothpaste
and mouthwash), camphor (in salves and lotions),
and very spicy foods. Homeopathic medicine should also
be handled with care, and should not be touched with the
hands or fingers, which may contaminate it.
Side effects
A homeopathic aggravation sometimes occurs during
initial treatment with homeopathic remedies. This
means that symptoms can temporarily worsen during the
process of healing. Although this is usually mild, the aggravation
can sometimes be severe. Homeopaths see aggravation
as a positive sign that the remedy is a good
match for the patient’s symptoms. The healing crisis,
which happens when the patient is undergoing treatment
for layers of symptoms, may also cause the patient to
feel worse before feeling better. Some patients can experience
emotional disturbances like weeping or depression,
if suppressed emotional problems led to the illness
in the first place.
Research & general acceptance
Since the early 1900s, when the American Medical
Association and pharmacists waged a battle against it,
homeopathy has been neglected and sometimes ridiculed
by mainstream medicine. Aside from politics, part of the
reason for this hostility is that there are some aspects of
homeopathy that have not been completely explained scientifically.
For instance, homeopaths have found that the
more they dilute and succuss a remedy, the greater effect it
seems to have on the body. Some homeopathic remedies
are so diluted that not even a single molecule of the active
agent remains in a solution, yet it still works; studies have
demonstrated this paradox, yet can’t explain it. Also,
homeopathy puts an emphasis on analyzing symptoms and
then applying remedies to these symptoms, rather than
working by classifying diseases. Thus, some people with
the same disease may require different homeopathic medicines
and treatments. Furthermore, conventional medicine
strives to find out how medicines work in the body before
they use them; homeopathy is less concerned with the intricate
biochemistry involved than with whether a remedy ultimately
works and heals holistically. For all these reasons,
conventional medicine claims that homeopathy is not scientific,
but homeopaths are quick to reply that homeopathy
has been scientifically developed and studied for centuries,
with much documentation and success.
There continue to be many studies that affirm the effectiveness
of homeopathic treatments. Among the most
celebrated, the British Medical Journal in 1991 published
a large analysis of homeopathic treatments that were
given over the course of 25 years. This project involved
more than 100 studies of patients with problems ranging
from vascular diseases, respiratory problems, infections,
stomach problems, allergies, recovery from surgeries,
arthritis, trauma, psychological problems, diabetes, and
others. The study found improvement with homeopathic
treatment in most categories of problems, and concluded
that the evidence was “sufficient for establishing homeopathy
as a regular treatment for certain indications.”
For example, a study in early 2002 was reported on in a
pediatric journal that showed symptom improvement for
children with uncomplicated acute otitis media (ear infection)
who received individualized homeopathic remedies.
Although the authors concluded that more research was
needed, results were positive enough to justify a larger study.